Brown or Copper
“Judge not, that ye be not judged.” Matthew 7:1
One of the many reasons I love my husband is his love of trees. Terry enjoys hiking through the forest under the canopy of trees. He marvels at big oak trees with their gnarly branches. While living in Wisconsin, he discovered a ginkgo tree at his work and couldn’t wait to show me their fan shaped leaves. Once, he joined our then teenagers and their friends in climbing a tree in Kitty Hawk, North Carolina. Even if a tree is diseased and dying, he mourns the inevitable cutting down. As we are driving, he remarks on the ghosts of trees that have met their demise on our usual routes. And one of his greatest dreams is to see the majestic redwood forests.
When we moved into our house, our yard had only one small maple tree that has more than doubled in size and breadth in the last twelve years. Though we did have some privet bushes and climbing roses, and we added a lilac bush, the yard had only that one solitary tree until six years ago. That spring, Terry wanted to plant some trees. It had been a particularly hard fall and winter for us personally, culminating in the devastating loss of his mother. Eva Jane, his mother, loved trees as well. She, too, remarked on trees and the beauty and shade they provided. And in honor of his mother, Terry wanted to grow something despite the great loss he felt. And maybe, in nurturing something, he would find peace and hope.

As with most decisions, we had very different ideas. I love anything that flowers and produces fruits. Terry, on the other hand, loves cedar trees, stately oaks, and other shade trees. We went to the local nursery and walked around, oohing, remarking, and maybe even debating a little on what trees we wanted to purchase. We finally compromised. We found a magnolia tree that seemed destined to be in our yard, with the species name “Jane Magnolia”, in honor of my late mother-in-law. We also found a crabapple tree, and Terry got his wish: an oak. Soon, he was digging holes and planting trees. He faithfully watered the trees all that summer to ensure they were well established before the coming winter.
The trees have grown since that spring. The magnolia blossoms each spring, and a sweet bird has built her nest in the tree for the last three years. The crabapple has spread its branches, while the oak thrives having added a protective layer of bark to its trunk as it also branches out across the yard. I often see my husband staring out into the yard, gazing at the trees with wonder and satisfaction.
But I am going to let you in on a little secret: I have borderline despised the oak tree each fall. The first year, despite turning a flat dull brown, the tree didn’t drop her leaves in late October. Instead, she clutched the leaves throughout the winter, appearing like she was in her final stages of life. Then in spring, when everything was brimming with life, the tree dropped her leaves, with new growth and new buds appearing. The dead brown leaves lying on the grass polluted my ideas of spring. As she continued to grow, her clutch of dead brown leaves grew as well. This pattern has continued for the last five years, the oak gripping its dead leaves in an apparent act of defiance. And in my mind, it was an eyesore in winter, when I look forward to fresh snow artfully covering the bare branches.
Terry researched briefly and found that some species of oak hold onto their leaves with no apparent explanation. This bothered me. Why didn’t we do research ahead of time and pick a proper leaf-dropping oak? He continued to love his tree, but I had major buyer’s remorse. He continued to remark on its’ growth, and I half listened to his praise.
Last week, I saw an Instagram post from Michaux State Forest casting Terry’s oak tree in an entirely new light. The post stated “here’s a reminder to look beyond the drab winter landscape on your next forest trek”. The post changed my dull brown leaves to “persistent copper-colored leaves” explaining that these oaks offer visual interest and a bit of mystery. They don’t lose their leaves like all the other trees due to a “quirk known as marcescence”. Scientists offer some possible explanations. It might be a way for a young tree to protect its lower branches from hungry deer. Or when the leaves do drop in spring, it might help protect the forest floor by aiding with moisture retention. But, for whatever reason, God created this tree with this apparent quirk for good reasons.
I like to believe I champion differences in people. I embrace cultural differences and love to hear stories about others’ traditions. I choose books that expand my knowledge and understanding of the world. I encourage others to follow their passions, even if it falls out of the norms of what is popular. And fundamentally, I believe that God has created us in His image, and that our way of making the world beautiful reflects His character.
But as much as I try to champion people, I still fall into the trap of being judgmental. Recently, someone I love reminded me of times I had pushed him to be something he wasn’t. I didn’t support his God-given personality trait of being an introvert. Yes, even as an introvert, you need community. Yes, even as an introvert, you need to be friendly and have good communication skills. But the need for space and solitude recharges an introvert so that they can be in community, be friendly, and communicate well. When that space is taken away, it can leave the person feeling trapped with a need to close off. But out of misguided love, I pushed this person too hard. It left him feeling uncomfortable and unsupported.
On the flip side, for a time in my life I was in a space dominated by introverts. My need for socialization was deemed needy, my outgoing enthusiasm was too much, and my communication skills too loud. And, like the introvert that I was pushing, I felt trapped, uncomfortable, and unsupported. I tried to be calmer, less outgoing, and quieter. But inside, I was withered and dying. And until I changed my space, where I could be more of who I am, I wasn’t flourishing.
Despite my previous disdain for that tree, the oak is thriving. It has grown several feet and even produced a few tiny acorns this year. But what if the tree had dropped its leaves? Is it possible that the deer would have stripped it of its tender branches during the winter? Is it possible that the tree would have stopped growing and flourishing?
God has made all of us unique. Some of us are extroverts who thrive at parties and meeting new people. Others are introverts, who need smaller spaces to connect. Some of us love spontaneity and flexibility, others like Excel spreadsheets and day planners. These are just a few of the ways we are different. And all these differences reflect the characteristics of God. I need to recognize that and not see the differences in others as “dull brown”, wishing or pushing them to be something they are not. And just maybe if I suspend judgment, what might seem like dull brown is actually beautiful copper, exactly the way God intended.




